Monday, April 8, 2013
Persepolis
I read Persepolis over the break before the semester started because I was so excited. Although I haven't seen the movie yet (I can't wait to,) I'd heard a bit about the story and was intrigued. Reading through it a second time in preparation for class allowed me to pick up on a few things that eluded my grasp the first time through, most likely as a result of my initial horror at some of the occurrences described in the novel, and due to my naiveté on the subject. Marjane Satrapi does an excellent job explaining in simple terms the complex and frightening history of Iran and the Islamic Revolution. The storybook quality of the text catered to my ignorance. While the narration is reflective, and clearly delivered by a much older, more mature Marjane, the language and the tone used in Persepolis is didactic and incumbent on the way children digest information -the subject material, however, involves the kinds of things children should never have to be confronted with. The disparity between the playfulness of the narration and the atrociousness of the subject matter is creepy. When I was a child, I played horses- I didn't play torture. I wanted to be a mermaid when I grew up, not a prophet.
The appearances that God as a character in the novel makes are crucial to understanding Persepolis in terms of a Bildungsroman. He makes His last appearance on page 70. Marjane yells at him, "Shut up, you! Get out of my life!!! I never want to see you again!" In this instance, Marjane doesn't want to believe in a God that could allow her "beloved Anoosh," her hero, to be executed. The next page reveals that "It was the beginning of the war" (71). It seems to me that the message embedded here is that people tend to lose their faith or question it most in times of war. On page 99, Mrs. Nasrine exclaims, "All my life, I've been faithful to the religion. If its come to this... Well, I can't believe in anything anymore..." It is around this time that Marjane ceases to view figures like God, Karl Marx, Fidel Castro, Leon Trotsky and Che Guevara as characters, or imaginary friends. Her proximity to war has sobered her.
The role of capitalism in Persepolis is important. One thing about the way the novel is written that I appreciated while reading, was that although the history lessons seem simplistic, they are considered from multiple angles, rather than merely the one that Marjane was subjected to in her own schooling. The way the book is written is such that describing a viewpoint automatically opens up a discussion for an examination of an opposing one. America is viewed as "decadent" by people in positions of authority. In the beginning of the novel the enforcing of the veil coincides with the closing down of bilingual schools in 1980, two things that from a child's standpoint felt oppressive. Children didn't understand why they had to wear the veil or why they had to be separated from their friends. Interestingly, it is America that Marjane ultimately gravitates towards, and it is American fashions and the American music scene that constitute Marjane's rebellion in her teenage years. Marjane chooses a new uniform of tight jeans, a denim jacket, Nike's and a Michael Jackson pin, and she proudly displays her Iron Maiden and Kim Wilde posters on her bedroom walls. Punk becomes the identity that Marjane chooses in order to set herself apart from the rest of her veiled schoolmates, and it so happens to directly conflict with the ideals she was raised on. Can't wait to see where this leads in Persepolis 2!
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I agree about how evocative this is--does this childhood seem normal in the way normal was mermaids
ReplyDeletei love that the child has the ability to declare a truth in the way adults would shield it or at least confuse it. So yes, it opens us up in terms of truth and discussion
good stuff
e
I really appreciated the history lesson of Persepolis, too. The fact that it came from a voice that is still very much tied to childhood, and that the narrative is so absorbing prevents all the information from seeming didactic. It's interesting, too, to see how children adjust to constant trauma: under the circumstances, which are certainly not "normal" they bring that into their play, which is a normal thing for a child to do. It is a bit jarring, but it is also poignant.
ReplyDeleteI like that Marjane questions what is going on the way children do, and that we see her figuring out contradictions and questioning those, too, such as her parents' stance on socialism as related to their position of privilege.
I read this book several years ago, but found that I had forgotten a lot of it. It was a real treat to read again, so much so that I blasted through the second book immediately.
I really like the way you describe the interaction of childhood voice and graphics with very adult and complicated subject matter. Satrapi does have a way of making the narration appear simple and straight-forward on the surface, which lends the scenes of the violent riots and stabbings a sort of emphasized importance. The idea of perspective is also constant throughout the story, like you say. There's always that underlying hint that this one particular account of what happened isn't necessarily the whole story, or the right or wrong way to understand such a complicated period in Iran's history.
ReplyDelete