Special Exits is a
sweet memoir about a tragic time in any person’s life – taking care of your
parents in their final days. Its easy to fall in love with all the characters
in this memoir as we see them struggle to help each other, through health and
financial problems, with unwavering love for one another.
Despite reliving a difficult time in the author’s life,
Joyce Farmer manages to make the ending sweet instead of tragic. With a name
like Special Exits and an ending
scene where she cuddles the cat who once hated her, I ended up closing the
final pages of the book with a smile on my face instead of tears.
The characters are so loveable! I loved reading the comics
closely and finding that Farmer had included small jokes like calling the
grocery store “Food for More” or Trader Old’s instead of Trader Joes (p56). All
those small additions in the illustrations made the book just a little more
enjoyable. Joyce Farmer’s sense of humor and light-heartedness made the book
fun to read.
Despite the light heartedness, I definitely did feel for the
characters. I love how deeply Joyce Farmer brought us into the lives of her
parents (even though she wasn’t living in the home with them, I wonder how she
knew so much about their daily lives. Were these panels guesses or accurate?).
I also found it really honorable that Joyce Farmer decided that the most
important parts of her life to share in her own memoir, were her paretnts’
final days (instead of just writing about herself). I have a lot of respect for
the author for that. Its easy to feel how much, and how selflessly, she loves
her parents.
She touches on a lot of heavy themes about the elderly – ex:
old love, fear of doctors/anxiety around examinations, attachment to the home
(immobility/inability to go out), feeling like a burden, cycle where old people
turn into babies again, loneliness, physical and emotional pain etc., self
diagnosing instead of going to a doctor etc.
I used to think that the feeling of being a burden was just
something that indian elderly folks felt, or other elderly folks who live in
the same homes as their children….but this book was eye-opening for me in that
sense. I wonder if elderly people feeling like they become a burden is
universal across all cultures? Or is that just for sick people in general?
Some scenes that were really powerful for me (for diff
reasons) were p57-59 where Lars is crying because he’s tired of taking care of
someone he loves so much. Also p62 where Laura is bathing Rachel…this scene was
kinda at the beginning of when Rachel started to lose her mind and Rachel
totally looks like a child in this picture with her arms up in the air, excited
to be dressed/bathed. It just reminds me of a cycle about how we are born
unable to take care of ourselves, and as our bodies age we return to that in
old age.
I thought it was a random addition to add the scenes about
abortion. I appreciated them but I wasn’t sure where Joyce Farmer was going
with these references – Rachel advices Sharalee to get an abortion, Laura and Rachel
talk about how abortions are necessary and women should make decisions that
have to do with their bodies, and then Sharalee comes back to thank Rachel. I
think the abortion issue brings Laura and Rachel closer, but I wonder if there
was something else that I wasn’t getting with this thread in the memoir.
I liked the parts where Lars sees death before passing away.
I thought that was a really interesting illustration that wouldn’t have been
possible in the same way without the graphics that a graphic memoir offers. And
then again when Lars sees death in the mirror while changing into his suit. It
was just interesting to see what an old persons final thoughts might be, or
Joyce’s interpretations of what they might be.
Again in this book, there was no critical analysis of race
or representations of minority folks. And this has happened in most of our
memoirs so far, but its still a little irritating. I guess not questioning the “dangerous
neighborhood” panel with a black kid playing basketball outside (p75) is normal
for Joyce Farmer’s memoir. I mean, I guess not everyone’s memoir involves
questioning racial stereotypes or degradation. Also, the image about their one
black friend “Charles” who they thought would help check up on her parents
during the Rodney King riots (and the image of him smiling like he’s of service
to any white folks who need his help) was weird for me (p82). But, again, I
guess everyone’s memoir doesn’t have to do with racism.
Overall, I did love the memoir because I thought it was a
really artful way of depicting a couple’s///someone’s parents last few days of
life. It was lighthearted, warm, touching etc. Esp when her and the cat become
buddies on the very last page J
Shaina,
ReplyDeleteyou hit on a lot here and i appreciate your overall evaluations of the different elements of the book. You engaged with the characters and the environment. We're going to take it a bit further in the class. Can't wait
e
I like that you talk about the humor in the book. It's the kind of humor you become accustomed to when you spend a lot of time around old people- corny, but actually very endearing. I was also wondering the same thing about whether certain parts of the book were just Laura speculating on what she imagines happened, or if she is filled in by someone on the events taking place. As for the whole abortion thing, I think in part it was an effort to give Rachel's character more purpose. The book makes her out to be a savior. Sheralee graduates from school and now has an awesome job all thanks to Rachel's advice. Without this bit, the reader might just think that Rachel is a wacko, bible-thumping, stereotypical, fat American. For Sheralee this is just one moment in a life full of stick out moments; for Rachel, in her old age, it means so much more.
ReplyDeletehmm thats an interesting way to think about the Sheralee story. i like that. thanks for replying :)
ReplyDelete