Let me start by saying I have never
taken into account how heavily presentation in a graphic novel mattered until I
read fun home this time. Having lost my copy I purchased freshman year at Mills
I downloaded it to my kindle, which shows only two boxes per page instead of
whatever the physical copy has. The two boxes shown by the kindle are on top of
each other in the middle of the page, with bright white free space around them.
My chef friend would call this “staging.” It seems to emphasize more of what Bechdel
is saying, and indeed, I had a deeper reading this time.
Bechdel seems to be a great fan of
themes. There is the literary theme that her and her father share and is
referenced in story and analogy form throughout the book. There is the Greek
myth theme, which she begins and ends with. Perhaps the most obvious is the
sexuality theme. In Bechdel’s memoir, sexuality, or the repression of it, is a
catalyst for suppressed hostility on her part, her parent’s torturous marriage
and her father’s death. In the end, Bechdel admits that perhaps she projects
the identity of “gay” and not bisexual or something else, so she can keep him
to herself.
In one of my other classes we’re
talking about Virginia Woolf and how she “tunnels.” By tunnel I mean introduce
a character or situation and then contextualize it with a background facts that
end up being stories in themselves. This happens over and over again in
Bechdel’s descriptions of her father; we learn more and more about him by this
technique being used. Bechdel also seems to use a circling technique as the
story isn’t completely linear. Such as with the snake story, Bechdel first
tells it, and then tells it again in her vignette about her journaling and
compulsions. This retelling of events brings depth the second time around, and
this is the first book we’ve read so far that utilizes this kind of revisiting.
-Trinidad
It was interesting to see her deliberate/anxious journal revisions as a younger person ("I think...") in relation to Fun Home's storytelling (with some context, allusions, etc.) and retelling (with more context, allusions, etc.).
ReplyDeleteyou're right about how the story snakes around and i didn't realize that the second time we revisit certain events it does bring more depth. thank you for pointing that out.
ReplyDeletei also think its interesting that the presentation on the kindle and a paperback book are so different considering that the kindle is probably around the same size as the book? that must have really changed the reading.
could use more analysis. pointing out one technique isn't quite a complete response. However, let me say, it's a good point and i think her use of time (and the use of qualifiers Jenny points out) definitely affects her status as a narrator.
ReplyDeletemore...
e